Can You Be Fired for Filing a Workers' Comp Claim in Florida?

No. Florida law makes it illegal for an employer to fire you, threaten to fire you, intimidate you, or coerce you because you made a valid workers' compensation claim or tried to claim benefits. That protection comes from section 440.205 of the Florida Statutes, and the Florida Supreme Court has held that it gives injured workers the right to sue their employer for damages, including lost wages and emotional distress.

The law does not, however, make an injured worker impossible to fire. An employer can still discipline or let go of an employee for a legitimate reason that has nothing to do with the claim. Most of these cases turn on one question: what was the real reason? This article explains how Florida's workers' comp retaliation law works, how these claims are proved, and what to do if you think you were punished for getting hurt on the job.

What does Florida law say about workers' comp retaliation?

Section 440.205 is a single sentence. It says that no employer shall "discharge, threaten to discharge, intimidate, or coerce" an employee "by reason of" the employee's valid claim for compensation or attempt to claim compensation under the Workers' Compensation Law.

Florida does not recognize a general common-law claim for retaliatory firing. But in Smith v. Piezo Technology & Professional Administrators, 427 So. 2d 182 (Fla. 1983), the Florida Supreme Court held that section 440.205 creates a statutory cause of action that an employee can bring in court. Florida appellate courts have since filled in several important details:

  • You do not have to be fired. The statute also covers threats, intimidation, and coercion. In Hornfischer v. Manatee County Sheriff's Office, 136 So. 3d 703 (Fla. 2d DCA 2014), the Second District explained that section 440.205 creates a cause of action for intimidation or coercion even when there is no discharge.

  • The claim does not have to be the only reason. Hornfischer also noted that the statute prohibits a discharge because of an attempt to claim compensation even if the employer had other reasons as well, and that the employee does not have to prove a specific retaliatory intent.

  • An attempt to claim benefits is protected. The statute's text protects an employee's "attempt to claim compensation," not only a formal claim that has already been filed or approved.

  • Public employers are covered. In Bifulco v. Patient Business & Financial Services, Inc., 39 So. 3d 1255 (Fla. 2010), the Florida Supreme Court held that the Legislature waived sovereign immunity for these claims when the state and its subdivisions act as employers, and that the presuit notice requirements of section 768.28(6) do not apply to retaliation claims brought against government employers under section 440.205.

That last point matters for city, county, school board, and state agency employees, who often assume they must send a formal notice of claim before suing. For a section 440.205 claim, the Florida Supreme Court has said they do not. Other claims against a government employer may have their own notice rules, so it is worth checking each one. (For a broader look at how protections differ for government workers, see our article on Florida whistleblower law for public and private employees.)

How do you prove you were fired because of a workers' comp claim?

Florida courts generally require an employee to prove three elements: (1) the employee engaged in statutorily protected activity, such as claiming or seeking workers' compensation benefits; (2) an adverse employment action occurred; and (3) the two were causally related. The Third District applied these elements in Miami-Dade County v. Guyton (Fla. 3d DCA 2023), and the Second District did the same in Hornfischer.

Courts usually analyze these cases with a burden-shifting framework borrowed from federal discrimination law. Once the employee shows the claim and the firing are not completely unrelated, the employer must offer a legitimate reason for its decision. The employee then has to show that the stated reason is not the real one, often called "pretext."

As the court observed in Hornfischer, employers rarely announce in writing that they are firing someone because of a workers' comp claim. Proof usually comes from circumstantial evidence, such as:

  • A stated reason for the firing that does not hold up when the facts are examined closely.

  • Emails, notes, or comments showing hostility toward the employee or the claim. In Hornfischer, internal emails reflecting a negative attitude toward the employee's claims were part of the evidence that sent the case to a jury, even though about six months passed between the claims and the firing.

  • Failure to follow the employer's own policies. In Guyton, the employee, a bus operator dismissed for long-term absenteeism more than a year after a work injury, argued that the employer did not follow its own policies after her injury. The Third District affirmed the jury's verdict in her favor.

  • Different treatment of the injured employee compared with coworkers who did not file claims.

  • Timing, such as a firing shortly after an injury report or a request for medical care.

These cases share a lot with other workplace retaliation claims, and the same kinds of evidence often matter.

What will the employer argue?

Employers usually say the employee was fired for misconduct, poor performance, attendance, or a reorganization. Florida courts give employers considerable room on those decisions. In Francois v. JFK Medical Center Limited Partnership (Fla. 4th DCA 2023), the Fourth District held that the "business judgment rule" applies to section 440.205 claims. Under that rule, the question is not whether the employer's decision was wise or fair, but whether the decision-makers honestly believed the reason they gave.

The Francois court affirmed summary judgment for the employer, explaining that the only link between the workers' comp claim and the firing was timing, which was not enough. The court also noted that under Florida's newer summary judgment standard, an employee's own statement that the employer is lying, standing alone, will generally not get a case to trial.

The practical lesson is that timing alone is rarely enough. A strong case usually has timing plus something more: an explanation that shifted, a rule applied only to the injured worker, a decision-maker who complained about the claim, or a stated reason that the records contradict.

What can you recover in a Florida workers' comp retaliation case?

In Scott v. Otis Elevator Co., 572 So. 2d 902 (Fla. 1990), the Florida Supreme Court held that an employer who violates section 440.205 has committed an intentional tort and may be liable for emotional distress damages. Depending on the facts, recoverable damages can include:

  • Lost wages and benefits from the date of the firing.

  • Lost future wages. Scott held that the employee did not have to prove that reinstatement was not a viable alternative in order to recover lost future wages.

  • Damages for emotional distress.

Scott also noted that section 440.205 does not authorize a court to order reinstatement. The remedy is money damages. A retaliation lawsuit is separate from the workers' compensation benefits claim itself, which is handled through the workers' compensation system.

Are there time limits?

Yes. Retaliation claims, like other legal claims, are subject to strict time limits, and the limits vary by claim and can change. A section 440.205 claim does not require filing an administrative charge with a government agency before suing.

A workplace injury can also raise other claims with their own, sometimes shorter, time limits. If the injury left you with a lasting impairment and your employer refused a reasonable accommodation or fired you because of it, you may also have a disability discrimination claim, which generally requires an agency charge first. Talk with a lawyer promptly about which time limits apply to you.

What to do now

  • Report the injury promptly. Tell your employer about a work injury as soon as possible, in writing if you can, and keep a copy.

  • Write down what happens next. Note dates, who said what, and any change in how you are treated after the injury report.

  • Keep documents you lawfully have. Save performance reviews, write-ups, schedules, texts, and emails you received in the normal course of your job. Do not take confidential company records you are not authorized to have.

  • Ask for the reason in writing. If you are fired or disciplined, a written explanation helps show later whether the reason changed.

  • Do not wait. These claims are subject to strict time limits that vary by claim and can change.

  • Get advice early. A lawyer can look at whether the facts support a retaliation claim under section 440.205, a wrongful termination claim under another law, or both.

Injured workers throughout Florida, from Jacksonville to the Panhandle and South Florida, have the same protection under section 440.205, because it is a statewide law that applies to private and public employers alike.

Related: Workplace Retaliation | Wrongful Termination | Jacksonville Employment Lawyer

Massey & Duffy, PLLC represents employees in workplace retaliation and wrongful termination cases in state and federal courts throughout Florida, including Gainesville, Jacksonville, Orlando, Tampa, Tallahassee, and Pensacola. To request a consultation, use our contact page or call (352) 505-8900.

This article is for general information only and is not legal advice. It describes the law as of the date it was published. Reading it does not create an attorney-client relationship. The law can change, and the outcome of any case depends on its specific facts. Past results do not guarantee a similar outcome.

Next
Next

Florida Whistleblower Law After Gessner: Why Public and Private Employees Face Different Rules