Can You Sue If a Dog Bites You in Florida? What About a Police Dog?

If a dog bites you in Florida, the owner is usually responsible for your injuries even if the dog never bit anyone before. Florida's dog-bite statute makes most owners strictly liable, which means you generally do not have to prove the owner was careless. Police dogs are different. A bite from a law enforcement K-9 is not handled under the strict-liability statute, but that does not leave you without options. Depending on what happened, you may have a negligence claim against the agency that owns the dog, a federal civil rights claim against the officers involved, or both.

Is a dog owner automatically responsible for a bite in Florida?

In most cases, yes. Section 767.04 of the Florida Statutes says the owner of any dog that bites a person is liable for the damages the person suffers, "regardless of the former viciousness of the dog" or whether the owner knew the dog was dangerous. The Florida Supreme Court has described this statute as making the dog owner essentially an insurer against bites, a departure from the older common-law rule that required proof of negligence. A separate statute, section 767.01, also makes owners liable for damage their dogs do to people.

The strict-liability rule applies when the person bitten was:

  • In a public place, such as a sidewalk, park, or store; or

  • Lawfully on private property, including the dog owner's own property. The statute says a person is lawfully on private property when invited there (expressly or by implication) or when performing a duty under state or federal law, such as a mail carrier delivering the mail.

Are there defenses to a Florida dog-bite claim?

There are a few, and they can make a real difference:

  • The bitten person's own negligence. Section 767.04 reduces the owner's liability by the percentage that the injured person's own negligence contributed to the bite. Florida's general comparative-fault statute, section 768.81, also says that in a "negligence action," which the statute defines to include strict-liability claims, a person found more than 50 percent at fault for his or her own harm cannot recover. Provoking a dog or ignoring clear warnings can therefore reduce or even eliminate a recovery.

  • The "Bad Dog" sign. If the owner had a sign displayed in a prominent place on the property, easily readable and including the words "Bad Dog," the owner generally is not liable under the statute for a bite on that property. That defense does not apply when the person bitten is under age 6, or when the injury was caused by the owner's own negligent act or omission.

  • Trespassing. The statute protects people in public places or lawfully on private property. Someone who is unlawfully on private property generally cannot rely on the strict-liability rule.

The statute also says its remedy is in addition to any other remedy under statute or common law, so a negligence claim may still be available in some situations even when the statute does not apply. These questions are fact-specific. A personal injury claim built on a dog bite often turns on details such as where the bite happened and what signs were posted.

What if a police dog bites you?

The strict-liability statute does not apply to a dog owned by a government agency. In McKinley v. Gualtieri (Fla. 2d DCA 2022), a man was bitten by a sheriff's K-9 while attending an event at a ballpark. The Second District Court of Appeal explained that Florida's waiver of sovereign immunity, section 768.28, lets people sue government agencies for the negligent or wrongful acts of their employees, but does not impose strict liability on the government. As a result, a person bitten by a dog owned by a government agency cannot sue the agency under section 767.04.

But the same court held that a person bitten by a police dog may sue the agency for ordinary common-law negligence. The court reasoned that handling a police dog is like operating a patrol car or handling a firearm: officers owe a duty of reasonable care to people within the foreseeable zone of risk their conduct creates. It also held that while the decision to use K-9 patrols may be discretionary, actually patrolling with the dog is operational, so sovereign immunity did not bar the claim.

Separately, section 767.16 exempts dogs owned or employed by law enforcement agencies from Florida's dangerous-dog classification and confinement rules.

Can you sue a police department or sheriff's office for a K-9 bite?

Usually the state-law negligence claim is brought against the agency, not the individual officer. Under section 768.28(9)(a), an individual government officer or employee generally cannot be held personally liable in tort for acts within the scope of employment. The exclusive remedy is ordinarily a claim against the agency or its head in an official capacity. The exception is when the officer acted in bad faith, with malicious purpose, or with wanton and willful disregard of human rights, safety, or property.

Claims against Florida government agencies also come with special rules that do not apply to suits against private dog owners, including:

  • A requirement to present a written claim to the agency, and in many cases to the Florida Department of Financial Services, before filing suit;

  • Statutory caps on how much can be collected from the agency; and

  • No punitive damages against the agency.

Missing a pre-suit requirement can sink an otherwise valid claim, which is one reason to get advice early from a civil litigation lawyer.

When is a police dog bite a civil rights violation?

When a police dog is used to stop or arrest someone, the bite is a use of force. Under the Fourth Amendment, the question is whether that force was objectively reasonable. Courts apply the factors from the U.S. Supreme Court's decision in Graham v. Connor, 490 U.S. 386 (1989): how serious the suspected crime was, whether the person posed an immediate threat to officers or others, and whether the person was actively resisting or trying to flee. A person whose rights were violated can bring a claim under 42 U.S.C. § 1983, the federal civil rights statute. Learn more on our police misconduct page.

The Eleventh Circuit, the federal appeals court covering Florida, has addressed K-9 force several times:

  • Priester v. City of Riviera Beach, 208 F.3d 919 (11th Cir. 2000): The court upheld a jury verdict where, on the plaintiff's account, he surrendered, lay down as ordered, and was not resisting, yet an officer ordered the dog to attack and let it attack him for at least two minutes. The court held that no reasonable officer could think that force was lawful. It also held that a second officer who watched the attack and had time to stop it could be liable for failing to intervene.

  • Crenshaw v. Lister, 556 F.3d 1283 (11th Cir. 2009): The court found a K-9 deployment reasonable where the suspect was believed to have committed armed robbery, had fled by car and on foot, and was hiding in dense woods at night, so officers could reasonably doubt his attempt to surrender.

  • Edwards v. Shanley, 666 F.3d 1289 (11th Cir. 2012): A driver ran from a traffic stop and hid in the woods. The court held that using a dog to track and initially subdue him was constitutional, but that allowing the dog to keep biting for several minutes while he lay face down, hands visible, begging to surrender, was excessive force that clearly established law prohibited.

The takeaway: deploying a dog against a fleeing or possibly armed suspect may be lawful, but continuing a bite after a person has surrendered and is under control can be a separate constitutional violation.

Officers sued under § 1983 usually raise qualified immunity, a defense that protects officials unless their conduct violated clearly established law. In K-9 cases, courts often compare the facts to Priester and Edwards to decide whether the officers were on notice. Our constitutional law page explains how these claims fit within broader civil rights litigation.

What to do now

If you or a family member was bitten by a dog, whether a neighbor's pet or a police K-9, these steps can help protect a potential claim:

  • Get medical care right away, and keep every record and bill.

  • Photograph the wounds over time, along with torn clothing and the location where the bite happened.

  • Write down what happened while it is fresh: who was present, what officers said, whether any warnings were given, whether you were told to surrender or lie down, and how long the bite lasted.

  • Collect names and contact information for witnesses. If the incident involved police, note the agency, officer names, and any report or case numbers.

  • Avoid giving recorded statements to an insurance company or agency investigator before getting legal advice.

Legal claims are subject to strict time limits, and some are short. Claims against government agencies also have notice requirements that must be satisfied before a lawsuit can be filed. The limits vary by claim and can change, so talk with a lawyer promptly about your situation.

Related: Police Misconduct | Personal Injury | Florida Civil Rights

Massey & Duffy, PLLC represents people in civil rights, police misconduct, and personal injury cases in state and federal courts throughout Florida, including Gainesville, Jacksonville, Orlando, Tampa, Tallahassee, and Pensacola. To request a consultation, use our contact page or call (352) 505-8900.

This article is for general information only and is not legal advice. It describes the law as of the date it was published. Reading it does not create an attorney-client relationship. The law can change, and the outcome of any case depends on its specific facts. Past results do not guarantee a similar outcome.

Next
Next

Can You Be Fired for Complaining About Discrimination or Harassment in Florida?